Pur Minerals Ratings and Reviews
Shop Now:
Top-Rated Products:
Top Rated Product
Product Reviews
Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Water-resistant, smudge-proof eye liner
Average Customer Rating:
Rating Snapshot (32 reviews)
5 stars
26
4 stars
2
3 stars
2
2 stars
2
1 star
0
28 of 32(88%)customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews
Review 1 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Maq96
Gender:Female
Skin Type:Combination
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Need design improvement
Date:August 10, 2012
Pros: water resistant
Cons: caps
"Agree with other reviewers - pur minerals needs to resign caps for pencil end and smudger end. So many times mixed them up and pencil "lead" mushed into smudger cap, making mess and wasting product. Also, both caps have cracked within 2 weeks of use in a padded makeup bag. Liner is natural color -mica brown and lasts. Hypoallergenic too."
Share this Review:
Review 2 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Suranganie
Location: Toronto, Ontario
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (golden undertones)
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Thumbs up
Date:March 3, 2012
"Chocolate Mica is natural looking dark brown that lasts the whole day. Smudge resistant. Smudger tip helps apply product for a natural look. Highly recommend."
Share this Review:
Review 3 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
sapphiregerty
Location: Calgary Canada
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (golden undertones)
Skin Type:Combination
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
EXCELLENT EYE PENCIL !!!!!!!
Date:December 6, 2011
Pros: best quality pencil i have worn!!
"These pencils are the best for application and long wear. I have purchased many colors and enjoy each one !!!!!!!! Excellent for sensitive skin."
Share this Review:
Review 4 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Schmorgan
Location: Eastern Canada
Age Group:25-34
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Very Light
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? No
OK eyeliner, keep smashing the end
Date:May 9, 2010
Pros: ok as eyeliners go
Cons: terrible packaging!!
"As eyeliners go this is not bad. I have to agree with a previous reviewer though that I have a HUGE gripe with the packaging! If you accidentally put the smudger cap on the eyeliner end it smooshes the pencil flat and wastes a lot of product. I've done this several times in haste and find it so frustrating!!! The caps shoud be interchangeable and I will never buy another one until this issue is fixed!!!!!!"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 5 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
PhylloCat
Location: Mississauga, Ontario
Age Group:16-24
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Light
Skin Type:Dry
Would you recommend this product to a friend? No
Date:April 27, 2010
Pros: black amethyst colour is pretty
Cons: need to tug and pull on eye lid
"I picked this up in Black Amethyst and was really quite excited to try it.
The reviews all sounded great, but I found that for me I really had to pull and stretch my eye lid to obtain a dark enough line.
It is ok if I use it to line the bottom of my eye, but I think I'll try the pur cream eye liner."
Share this Review:
Review 6 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Chris
Location: Alberta, Canada
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Very Light
Skin Type:Dry
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
the best
Date:August 20, 2009
"I have always had problems with smudgy eyeliner. This is the first time in my makeup history I have eyeliner that stays put. Love it! love it! Love it! One request, please make a taupe."
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 7 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Christytee
Location: Cumberland, RI
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (golden undertones)
Skin Type:Combination
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Easy to Apply
Date:July 31, 2009
Pros: lasts all day, does not feel tight or dry, does not irritate eyes, does not run or smear
Cons: need a prettier shade of purple :o)
"Since my eyesight is not what it used to be, applying eyeliner can be quite a chore; but not with THIS Defining Pencil! I purchased it in the dark blue shade and am now anxiously awaiting for the dark green shade to arrive. This liner feels creamy-smooth and lasts all day long (until you wash it off) without budging! No skin reactions, no burning eyes, and no problems! Who could ask for more? LOVE IT...thank you for yet another terrific product, Joli!"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 8 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Milagro
Location: Lonoke, AR
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (pink undertones)
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Stays put all day---no crumbling!!
Date:March 16, 2009
Pros: i think it would last 24 hours!, very gentle touch to the eye., it blends beautifully!, colors are very friendly with all tones/eye colors
Cons: costs more than i would like.
"I've tried eyeliners from low-end price to high-end and everything inbetween trying to find one that didn't flake off within the first hour at work!! Cake-type, liquid, felt-tip pen, wooden pencils (OUCH!!), and twist ups. Round, flat, diagonals, ...the list could go on and on. But my searching ended last week when I purchased Chocolate Mica for my eyes and Almandine for my brows. It should be illegal to have anyother eyeliner in your make-up kit!! Ten hours after I drew my liner on this morning and it is still from corner to corner, bottom and top lids---and no flakes on my face!!! WOW!!! No more Tammy Faye Baker eyes!!! Don't leave this website without ordering it!!!"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 9 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
littlepiggy
Location: Utah
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Light
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Extremely easy on the tender skin of the eye
Date:February 25, 2009
"The peridot pencil is beautiful and glides on smoothly. No tugging or pulling of the eyelid is necessary. Does not smudge during the day and remains on the eye until removed."
Share this Review:
Review 10 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
TLONG
Location: Westminster, SC
Age Group:35-44
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Tan
Skin Type:Dry
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
THE BEST!
Date:February 1, 2009
"I love this eye liner! For some one who has severe skin allergies, suffering from watery eyes and sweating eyebrows from most liners, I have NO problems with this one, and it lasts forever as well. I've tried the other so called "pure mineral" make-up, with no good results. I'll never buy anything else."
Share this Review:
Review 11 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
ThrilledWithPUR
Age Group:35-44
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (pink undertones)
Skin Type:Combination
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Fresh Look Without Being Too Bold
Date:January 30, 2009
Pros: nice blender on the end, will last a long time
"I was able to try this on in store before purchasing. Wow. It blends in wonderfully and looks fresh and keeps my line perfectly. Who could ask for more? You don't need to use much either for a good look. As with everything else PUR, I am very impressed."
Share this Review:
Review 12 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Shellee24
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
I still can't believe it!
Date:January 30, 2009
"I have always had a problem with eye liners smearing and I always looked like a raccoon at the end of the day. I ended up getting my eyes tatooed because the problem was that bad. The tatoos failed. I decided to try this more expensive eye defining pencil after tying all the brands offered in the store. This was the only eye defining pencil I have ever owned that does not smudge or run. Thank you purminerals."
Share this Review:
Review 13 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
jars
Location: Boston, MA
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (pink undertones)
Skin Type:Dry
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
love the blue
Date:January 29, 2009
"The pencil is easy tom use, lasts all day and the blue brightens the white in your eyes."
Share this Review:
Review 14 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Debbie
Location: PEI
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (golden undertones)
Skin Type:Combination
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Great Product
Date:January 29, 2009
"The eye pencils are very good, they glide on smoothly and stay put."
Share this Review:
Review 15 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Anna
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
I love it!
Date:January 28, 2009
"this is the best eye pencil I have ever had. Stays all day long, colors are great. I love black amethyst, peridot and especially polished stone."
Share this Review:
Review 16 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Jakesmom
Location: New Brunswick, Canada
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Light
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? No
change the caps, please
Date:January 16, 2009
Pros: goes on smoothly and stays put
Cons: put the wrong cap on and wreck the pencil
"I have a suggestion for the caps. I have, on several occaisions, put the smudger cap on the pencil end and broke the pencil into the cap. I believe this is a packaging design flaw, because both caps should be interchangeable. This caused me to waste precious eyeliner, and although I love the product, I feel that I don't want to waste my money, or the time remembering which cap goes where. A cap change would keep my business!"
1 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review:
Review 17 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
Sierra
Location: Butler, PA
Age Group:35-44
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Light
Skin Type:Dry
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
stays all day
Date:January 13, 2009
"It glides on easily, stays all day and washes off easily. Well worth it!"
Share this Review:
Review 18 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
shabnam
Location: kingston, on
Age Group:35-44
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (golden undertones)
Skin Type:Combination
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
best problem solver
Date:January 12, 2009
Pros: addictive
"Just recently purchased this color onyx, really good for my eyes, glides on smoothly, will not smudged or makes your eyes looks like a raccoon. Best compliment I have comes from my husband. Encouraged me to use it everyday."
Share this Review:
Review 19 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
BabyBlues
Location: Ottawa, Canada
Age Group:45-54
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Medium (pink undertones)
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Glides on
Date:January 12, 2009
"I LOVE these...they go on like liquid eyeliner but are easier to use and forgiving. I love the fact that the line smudger is right on the pencil. There is no tugging or pulling around the eye at all.
I find that the product lasts a long time. One pencil lasts me at least a couple of months.
Sometimes I find it hard to put on over my shadow on my lid so I put a thin line on my lid then my shadow and then I put another line of the pencil...it works beautifully."
Share this Review:
Review 20 for Mineral Eye Defining Pencil with Smudger
Overall
RockabillyGirl
Age Group:16-24
Gender:Female
Skin Tone:Very Light
Skin Type:Normal
Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes
Best Mineral Eyeliner!!
Date:January 7, 2009
Pros: stays put all day
"This is absolutlely the best mineral eyeliner that I have tried, it stays put all day without smudging and the colors are beautiful!"
Share this Review:
