Pros: nice brush on end, goes on smooth, stays on well, blends well in brows thanks to brush
Cons: shiny color, too brown for lip liner

"This works fine as an eyeliner and a brow pencil, but the "natural" is much to brown to be a lip liner for me. Also, the brown is shiny/sparkly, so I won't reorder it for brow or eyeliner. It stays put very well and goes on easy enough. I like the brush on the end. It would be better if the caps were interchangeable, so I would stop accidently squishing (wasting) the pencil into the shorter brush cap (but that could just be me). :)"